[COMP2012] Object-Oriented Programming and Data Structures[]
Semester of Enrollment: 2014 Spring
Instructor: Gary Chan, QUAN Long(權龍)
Grade: Not Bad
Comments:
我自己係QUAN Long個班，不過一路都有sit Gary個堂。QUAN Long感覺上唔係好熟C++，上堂又好似無prepare過咁，次次都要望住張slide 10幾秒先有野講，原本諗住去到data structure會好d，點知都仲係咁:o)
仲有佢d slide真係好核突，紫色底黑色/白色字，字體又差。相反Gary就好好多，講野較流暢，仲有真係會寫d code出黎比你睇，唔係喺度齋講。
Grade既分佈唔是好清楚，不過兩個instructor 考同一份卷(midterm,final都係)，唔知係咪QUAN Long教得差d，QUAN Long個班既mean係低過Gary個班，但係分開比grade的，所以其實唔洗擔心。
Assignment唔算太難，係最尾個份要用長d時間，lab超hea超簡單。
[]
Semester of Enrollment: 2015 Spring
Instructor: MAK, Brian Kan Wing
Grade: Fair(整體)/Good(個人認為)
Comments: 想hea過Spring COMP2012既話,下面既comment可忽視.Fall sem應該workload唔重再加上過骨相對易. (若果仲係Quan Long教2012的話) Workload呢期唔算輕.
事關上次睇Brian COMP2011 Lecture video既時候, Brian話佢會教今期既COMP2012. 另一個亮點就係教過2012H既CK Tang都有教今期2012,遇着呢個instructor workload肯定喊出黎. (佢出D PA唔算去到做唔到,不過真係要花時間去諗)
今期COMP2012同之前幾期有出入,以下3個要點唔同:
- 唔會做任何COMP2011 Review,但會webpage有2011條website link俾自己click返review. COMP2011 pointer/class 唔熟既話唔建議今期take(非COMP major), 好多野都要用番,你catch up唔上既話好大機會gg.
- Mid-Term前講完大部分OOP;Mid-Term後最後4weeks主力data structure.內容比近幾期既多少少
- Mid-Term/Final考核模式同COMP2011既類似, 出題模式唔同之前果幾期COMP2012,深左少少.
唔知前果幾期係唔係一樣由PA2先開始chur(待求證),不過今期由PA2開始chur, code量同Tasks數量唔少,建議一出PA幾日後都要開波. (PA1整String Set,PA2自學QT Programming整小畫家,PA3用Hash Table整Reg科system.)
我official對Brian,但兩個instructor我都有上,CK 要求高,同埋感覺佢重implementation多過重C++,佢上堂點樣我諗MSSSUG對佢COMP2012H同COMP4411既描述都夠細緻,唔點多講.
至於Brian,佢用ipad教,教得慢,好多program上既位都會講到好detail,D program都會上堂demo出黎. 英文流利, 口音試正,上堂氣氛唔算差,鍾意學生上堂問問題.個人認為佢教OOP好過教Data Structure少少.
兩個instructor用同一份notes教,亦都係兩組一齊拉curve俾grade. Mid-Term/Final唔算易做,不過題數唔多,concept熟應該夠時間做,睇清楚D題目點做就應該做到.
雖然Brian話俾around 15% A range,條grade mean應該同COMP 2011相近.不過前提你D PA同WA冇乜甩漏, Mid-Term/Final過80分既話都好大機會A Range, 可能關Mid-Term/Final條mean都相對較低緣故啦. 而Mid-Term個Histogram show得低於30人過80分或樓上, Final冇出Histogram,應該同mid-term差唔多.
For reference Mid-Term 60/100 sd 18/100 Final mean 60/100 sd 20/100
Grading: (Grading Scheme同上期Fall既COMP2011既應該差唔多)
Passing Line:(total score > X) AND (midterm score * 0.25 + final exam score * 0.35 >= 12)
X will be determined by the instructors at the end of the semester.
PA 24% 3份 WA 6% 1份 Lab 10% 9個,同COMP2011既Lab grading policy一樣 (不過人人滿分咁滯)
Mid-Term 25% (Around Week 8) Final 35%
PA1/Lab/WA Full, PA2/PA3接近full, Mid-Term above 1.2sd, Final above 0.9sd,最後A. 個人覺得唔錯,起碼呢個分以COMP2011既standard既話真係頂盡A-/B+.